The news
New York City's click-to-cancel rule took effect on Thursday, October 1, requiring businesses that sell subscriptions to city residents to make cancelling as straightforward as signing up. PYMNTS reported that it is the first municipal click-to-cancel rule in the United States.
The rule is enforced by the city's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP). According to the city's official page, companies must clearly explain subscription terms, clearly disclose consumers' rights when buying or cancelling, and let customers cancel using the same method they used to sign up. Businesses also cannot charge customers to send back items they received for free.
The rule covers subscriptions offered to New York City consumers regardless of where the business is based, according to an analysis by law firm Skadden. Civil penalties start at $525, and businesses may also be required to refund consumers, according to the city. PYMNTS listed other practices the rule targets, including delayed cancellations, failing to notify customers of changed terms and hiding auto-renewal policies.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani framed the rule in terms of symmetry, as quoted by PYMNTS: "If a company can take your money with one click," customers should be able to get it back the same way. PYMNTS reported that the rule followed Executive Order 10, signed January 5, 2026, which directed DCWP to address deceptive subscription practices, and that a complaint portal opened at the same time.
Residents can file complaints online, by mail or by fax, with forms in 13 languages, the city says. DCWP reviews complaints and may assign a mediator between the consumer and the business.
The numbers
- Minimum civil penalty
- $525
- Effective date
- October 1, 2026
- Languages for complaint forms
- 13
Why CEOs should care
For any company that bills New York City residents on a recurring basis, from software and streaming to gyms and meal kits, the first task is a cancellation audit. If customers can sign up online but must call to quit, that flow likely needs to change. Product and legal teams should map every sign-up channel and confirm an equal cancel path exists for each.
For CFOs, retention numbers that depend on friction are at risk. Model what churn looks like if cancellation becomes one step, and shift budget toward retention offers customers can decline easily. Because the rule turns on where the customer is, not where the business is, out-of-state and online sellers should not assume they are exempt.
For general counsel, the patchwork is growing. PYMNTS reported that more than half of US states have auto-renewal laws and that the Federal Trade Commission's national click-to-cancel rule was vacated in July 2025 on procedural grounds. Building to the strictest standard across jurisdictions is usually cheaper than maintaining different flows by location.
The bigger picture
With the federal rule struck down, states and now a city are filling the gap. New York City's market size means many national subscription businesses will adjust for everyone rather than run a separate flow for one city, which can make a local rule a de facto national standard. Other cities may look at the model.
What’s next
Watch for DCWP's first enforcement actions and complaint volumes from the new portal, which will show how aggressively the rule is applied, and for other cities or states adopting similar language.
What “Fact-checked” means
Fact-checking means testing a story’s facts against the evidence before it is published. This story went through at least two separate checks before this version was published.
- What we checked
- Its names, figures, dates, job titles, quotes and who said what were checked against the story’s sources, including its main source where it could be opened. The headline was checked for accuracy and overstatement.
- How
- A first check reviewed the whole story. If it passed, a second, skeptical check went back to the sources to look for mistakes in the most important facts. If a check flagged the story, it was edited to fix the problems found, and a separate re-check then reviewed the whole story again.
- Who
- The checks are made by our newsroom, as steps kept separate from the writing, under rules set by our editor, Hussein Mukhtar. A story the checks still flag is held for the editor, who decides whether it is fixed, published or dropped.
- If something is wrong
- “Fact-checked” does not mean error-free. If a material error is found after publication, we correct the story and add a note saying what changed. Report an error
