Skip to content
TECH CEO Daily

Apple asks Supreme Court to overturn App Store contempt ruling in Epic Games case

The justices will decide whether a company can be held in contempt for breaking the spirit of an injunction, a question that shapes what developers pay Apple.

By · Editor

Added to archive · Covers events of September 14, 2026 · 3 min read · Fact-checked

The 60-second brief

  • 1On September 14, 2026, Apple filed its Supreme Court merits brief seeking to overturn the App Store contempt ruling Epic won.
  • 2Apple argues the 75-word injunction did not explicitly bar commissions; its earlier link-out fees ran from 12 to 27 percent.
  • 3Epic's brief is due November 13; developers should model several fee outcomes for linked purchases.

The news

On September 14, 2026, Apple (AAPL) filed its opening Supreme Court brief seeking to overturn the App Store contempt ruling Epic Games won in 2025, which barred Apple from collecting fees on purchases made through links to outside websites.

The Supreme Court agreed on June 30, 2026, to hear the case, Apple Inc. v. Epic Games, Inc. (No. 25-1311), but limited its review to one question: whether a party can be held in civil contempt for violating the spirit of an injunction that does not address the conduct at issue, or only for violating an order that clearly and unambiguously bans it.

The dispute traces back to a 2021 injunction, issued under California's Unfair Competition Law, that required Apple to let developers link users to other ways to pay, according to 9to5Mac. MacRumors reported that Apple's compliance came with fees of 12 to 27 percent on linked purchases, and that few developers used the option. In April 2025, U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers found Apple in contempt and barred it from collecting any fees on linked purchases in the US App Store.

According to MacRumors, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the contempt finding but concluded that barring all commissions was excessive, returning the matter to the district court to determine a reasonable fee.

In its brief, Apple argued that civil contempt requires an order giving clear notice that the conduct is prohibited, and that the Ninth Circuit's spirit-of-the-injunction standard is an outlier, 9to5Mac reported. MacRumors noted that Apple repeatedly pointed to the original injunction's length of just 75 words; the order did not explicitly prohibit commissions. Epic CEO Tim Sweeney responded on X that Apple's PR team had begun sharing "muddled talking points" with the press, and said Epic was fighting for the rights of all developers, according to 9to5Mac.

The numbers

Apple's earlier fee on link-out purchases (MacRumors)
12% to 27%
Length of the 2021 injunction, per Apple
75 words
Supreme Court docket number
25-1311
Epic Games' merits brief due
November 13, 2026

Why CEOs should care

For CFOs at companies that sell digital goods or subscriptions to US iPhone users, the case puts a price on a channel many have started to use. The contempt ruling barred Apple's fees on linked purchases, the Ninth Circuit opened the door to a reasonable fee set by the district court, and Apple is asking the justices to throw out the contempt finding altogether. Model at least three cases: no Apple fee on link-outs, a court-set fee, and whatever terms follow if Apple wins, and avoid long-term pricing commitments that assume today's terms are permanent.

For product and security leaders, linking out moves checkout from Apple's payment system to your own web flow. That means your team, not Apple, owns payment security, fraud screening and refunds for those purchases. The work is worth doing only if the fee savings justify it, so tie the investment to the legal outcome and keep the in-app purchase path ready as a fallback.

For boards and general counsel, the question reaches beyond Apple. A ruling for Apple would make it harder for courts to punish companies whose compliance plans follow the letter of an order; a ruling for Epic would signal that creative compliance carries contempt risk. Any company operating under an injunction or settlement should ask counsel which reading its own compliance plan relies on.

The bigger picture

The case sits at the center of a years-long fight over App Store economics. According to 9to5Mac, Apple set out its compliance plan in January 2024 with a commission of up to 27 percent, which the district court later found violated the spirit of the injunction. Apple also tried to pause the lower-court proceedings: on August 12, 2026, it asked Justice Elena Kagan for a stay, and she denied the application on August 13 after a brief administrative stay, according to the docket and SCOTUSblog.

What happened next

Between September 16 and September 21, 2026, nine amicus briefs were filed, by our count of the docket, including from the Chamber of Commerce of the United States, the Computer & Communications Industry Association, Chamber of Progress and a group of former federal antitrust enforcers. On September 21, the United States filed a brief supporting neither party. Epic's brief is due November 13, according to the docket; 9to5Mac reported that Apple's reply is due December 14 and that argument could come as early as January 2027.

What “Fact-checked” means

Fact-checking means testing a story’s facts against the evidence before it is published. This story went through at least two separate checks before this version was published.

What we checked
Its names, figures, dates, job titles, quotes and who said what were checked against the story’s sources, including its main source where it could be opened. The headline was checked for accuracy and overstatement.
How
A first check reviewed the whole story. If it passed, a second, skeptical check went back to the sources to look for mistakes in the most important facts. If a check flagged the story, it was edited to fix the problems found, and a separate re-check then reviewed the whole story again.
Who
The checks are made by our newsroom, as steps kept separate from the writing, under rules set by our editor, . A story the checks still flag is held for the editor, who decides whether it is fixed, published or dropped.
Archive story
It was written after the event. Its dates were checked against the date of the event, including the dates of any later developments it reports.
If something is wrong
“Fact-checked” does not mean error-free. If a material error is found after publication, we correct the story and add a note saying what changed. Report an error

How we fact-check →

Companies in this story

AppleEpic GamesApp StoreSupreme Court

Earlier coverage of Apple

All Apple coverage →

Written by

Editor · Technology & Business Writer

Hussein is a writer and business technology enthusiast focused on the intersection of technology, entrepreneurship, finance, artificial intelligence, and digital innovation.

CoversAICybersecurityBig TechSaaSStartupsFintech

About this story. Researched from primary sources whenever they are available and fact-checked before publication.

Published by Tech CEO Daily, an independent publication. Masthead · Editorial standards

Follow Tech CEO Daily on Facebook for the day’s top stories in your feed.

Free newsletters

The technology briefing for people running businesses.

Daily, weekly, bi-weekly or monthly. You choose.

How often

The Daily Brief · Monday to Saturday, 7 a.m. ET

Free forever. One click to unsubscribe. We never sell your email.